Introduction
In this 21st century, the words ‘Motivation’ and ‘Performance’ have great value. As you know, both of these words will go hand-in-hand. Now, in almost all organizations, the reward system is based on performance which is called performance appraisal. At the same time, criticism comes in motivation package for the improvement of employee’s skills. In comparison to present world, in early times the rewards are just the offered wage and motivations are the corporate punishments. This literature review lights you with some of current motivation based performance approaches at some of the organizations or workplaces around the world.
Motivation and Performance
What is motivation? What is performance? From work and organization perception, motivation is the stimulus to achieve high performance. On the other hand, performance is outcome of proper motivation. As we all know, human beings are not machine, so they will have their own ups and downs in their performance. None can make humans a machine. But good managers can make them to behave like a machine. For that managers should know how to motivate their employees properly. The pioneers in motivation based performance are Mary Parker Follett (1918) and Elton Mayo (1933, 1945). According to their perception, resources can develop or collapse an enterprise. The human resource frame platform is based on the following assumptions. Organizations exist to serve human needs, and both organization and workers need each other because organisations need ideas, energy, and talent. On the other hand, people need careers, salaries, and opportunities. When the individual and organization fit is poor, one or both suffer. And if the fit is good, it benefits both. Wegmans also said that his organisation serves the needs of his organisations customer with keeping in mind that the organisation can achieve its goal only if it fulfil the needs of his employees.
In the view of Shields John, Performance does not mean just how ‘high’ or ‘low’, but it means different based on the perceptions that you are looking at with, like, how it is defined and measured? Who is and what purpose, it is defined and measured? According to production manager performance is labour productivity and for a customer it might be product quality or cost-attractiveness. But for an employee in the production line, performance is his ability to do good job based on the income security, and workplace health and safety. These varied definition of performance lights into two important aspects of performance. It is a remarkable process which is subjective, constructed, open-ended, and multidimensional. Performance is not only an individual phenomenon. It has group and organisation-wide dimensions, each with inputs, processes and results that parallel those operating at the individual level. In this sense, performance can be thought of as having sequential and scalar dimensions.
Difficulties in Motivation and Performance
According to Pritchard, People work for different reasons. Some people work for satisfaction; they feel good by doing good work and feel bad about the poor work. One of the job performance measure (Borman, 2004) concerns in manufacturing companies is focused on improving productivity of workers. Greguras (1996) describes that an employee can contribute in achieving the organization objectives through completing the assigned job in time. It is not possible to improve the performance of your employee based on the benefits attained only from the Organization. Improvement in performance has to achieve from your employees satisfaction. If an employee is satisfied, that employee will be happy and will be in higher energy level or excitement. This satisfaction motivates him to do more work in smarter way. In turn the individual performance and organizational performances increases. Managers have to motivate employees based on strong needs, basics needs, etc. None of us can able to get a clear picture of our own needs, then how will a manager gets the need of someone else.
One of the other barriers in motivating an employee is the changes in the objectives of Organization, arbitrary performance standards, the number of resources to get the huge work done, feedback mechanisms for the improvement of employees in criticism and disrespectful tone. All these things will make the way to lose the good presence of mind for doing good work. These are also called disincentive factors in an organisation. People likes to control their work, people do not want to be held accountable for things they cannot control. People want feedback but not in the form of judgement. People want to valued, people do not want to waste their time. In a boarder view motivation is the process of changing one’s energy into one’s satisfied needs. It means making an employee to get completely focused to do the desired task of Organisation. For that, Managers should know his employees energy pool, which is the amount of physical, mental, and emotional resources a person has available to apply to different actions or tasks.
Another trouble comes in motivating your employees are the divergences. Each of your employees is different; they might be from different culture, economic levels, values, etc. Due to these divergences, you need to motivate your employees in their suitable way. For that you have to understand your employees desires, why they work in your organization, what are their goals, what are their hobbies, how they refresh when they are tired, etc. All these information guides you to motivate in your employees in a personalized manner. It is easy to say, but in practical, it is a hard task. Also, with greater diversity the challenge of motivation will also increase. In this scenario, the managers have to avoid demotivation due to frequent conflicts among groups of employees and within diverse groups. To motivate employees in diverse groups is a very elusive task.
One of the best ability to human is the ability to think. Because of this ability, you cannot use the same way of motivation for a long time. Humans need changes according to time. If you motivate your employee based on old motivational assumptions, your work will go in vein. The motivation is an ongoing and innovative process.
How to Overcome Difficulties in Motivation and Performance
One way of bracing employee is to provide effective motivation, which makes them more satisfied with what they are doing and committed to their jobs. They are motivated with money, but it is not the only motivator. There are other incentives which can also serve as motivators. As we all know, for achieving an effective work performance in an organization, work motivation is one of key factor as put by Luthans (1998). The new technologies, time management, leadership effectiveness will also to considered to understand how they relate to work performance. Although there are different features, all of these features are inter-related. For example, to motivate your employees, you should possess good leadership qualities which is a central feature of organisational performance. A good leader can direct their subordinate’s efforts towards the goals and objectives of the organization. There must be an appropriate form of behaviour to enhance performance. Based on the leaders ability to achieve effective performance from others, the leadership is defined. Akinboye (2005) defines leadership as managers motivating workers to work for certain aims that represent the values and the motivations, the wants and needs, the aspirations and expectations of both managers and workers.
With greater diversity, the probability of occurring human relation mistakes increases which result in low performance. In this situation, mistakes might happen due to different personalities, past experiences, partiality in leadership, etc. Because of these reasons, there is no one theory or model that can help all managers to motivate all employees for all time. Gordon (1996) notes, that the motivational needs became paramount when your workforce becomes more diverse and recognizing. The employee’s position and status in the organization, age, gender education marital status or any other socio economic characteristic has to be considered during motivation process. To overcome these issues, your managers should use a contingency approach to find the appropriate motivational theories to follow (Kreintner and kinicki, 1995). You can change behaviour of your employees by understanding the components of motivation, which are action, result, evaluations, outcomes and needs satisfaction, and how they work together.
For the effective performance management, the organisation has to validate the performance standards and measures which are directly relevant to what is required in the job position or role involved. Reliability, cost-effectiveness and felt-fairness are the other key requirements for effective performance. A Performance management system should meet the test of felt-fairness, both in terms of the decision-making process involved, or procedural fairness and the outcomes delivered, or distributive fairness.
Elgenhuis suggests a way to overcome performance difficulties by creating a winning organizational climate. In organization with a winning climate there is willingness to go and above and beyond the call of duty, to ‘go the extra mile’. This has a direct impact on the performance of the organization and also makes people to stay with organisation for long time.
Commonly Used Methods
To improve performance, Honda provided better work environment based on survey which boosted results. In Europe, large number of organisations started taking feedbacks in the second half of 1990s.
Managers find a confusing array of regulations and procedures standing in their way when they seek to reward good performance. (Alan K. Campbell, 1978) In spite of pervasive difficulties encountered by all public managers, Campbell’s experiment with merit based compensation was good. All public hr managers started to fairly motivate and reward public employees for better performance is a recurring and consistent theme of public human resource management literature and practice. Another method is the effective reward system and an effective performance appraisal system (Badway, 2007) In this method, employee can accommodate his family and also allowed to have a say in decision making of the work they carried out.
The contemporary theories of motivation are rooted in the principle of hedonism (Kreitner and Kinicki, 1995), states that people seek pleasure and avoid pain. Moorhead and griffin (1995) suggest that the drive to satisfy some important needs is the common goal in various theories of motivation. According to Maslow’s, managers have to concentrate in physiological needs by paying reasonable wage and providing comfortable physical environment.
According to Falcone Paul, for progressive performance, Organisation has to develop people’s skills and valuing individual. While communicating the inabilities to an employee, organisation has to use polite way of communicating instead of harsh way. He suggests organisations to use sentences starting with “I expect...” This polite approach will construct your employees. You can help your employee to succeed in his job and in turn help in achieving your organisations goal, by taking a little care in your communication. Training or special direction to be provided, whenever possible, it’s best to address a problem with positive tools as opposed to negative methods. Training is a kind of punishment, a positive punishment. You should help the employee succeed on her job. Even if discipline must be administered in the form of a warning, it should still be delivered hand in hand with training and other affirmative employer efforts. Keep in mind as well that training is the glue that binds people to a company: Everyone likes learning new things and developing new skills. And training, more than anything, helps people reinvent their hobs in light of their company’s changing needs. Although motivation is internal and not external, noting drives an employee to renewed commitment more than being challenged and stimulated by a new learning curve.
Conclusion
According to Kroth(2007), even though scholars proposed integrated motivational theories, there is no generally accepted models for all employee motivation. In this review, you can find many theories, but none of the theories can be used for a long time. To achieve a good performance, you should motivate your employees in an appropriate way. To find an appropriate way, managers should continuously follow your employees and has to find out what are their current needs and desire. These difficulties necessitate the need for human resource management team in an Organization.
References
- European Journal of Economics, Finance and Administrative Sciences, no. 16, pp. 2-8.
- Pritchard, Robert 2008, Managing Motivation: A manager’s Guide to diagnosing and improving motivation
- Kogan Page, 2008, HR Strtegy for the High Performing Buisness: Inspiring success through effective human resource management
- Wigfield, Allan; Eccles, Jacquelynne S. 2002, Deveolpment of achievement motivation
- Condrey, Stephen E, 2010, Handbook of Human resource Management in Government
- Falcone, Paul, 2010, 101 sample write-Ups for documenting employee performance problems: A Guide to Progressive Discipline & Termination
- Shields, John, 2007, Managing Employee Performance and Reward: Concepts, Practices, Strategies Lee G.Bolman & Terrence E. Deal, 2005, Reframing Organisations Artistry, Choice, and Leadership